Auto Insurance Center is a great place to get multiple car insurance quotes in Michigan for many different levels of coverage. Cheapest Auto Insurance Quotes in Michigan. Michigan Auto Insurance Fraud. The cost of insurance fraud in the state of Michigan amounts to millions of dollars every year. Some of Michigan’s auto insurance fraud is overt. To do so, you will need to speak with several Michigan car insurance companies to get car insurance quotes based on your own personalized factors. Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Michigan for Seniors. In Michigan, 14% of the population is age 65 or older, and it is the fastest growing segment of the state’s population. While the state. While the national average for car insurance is usually between $1,200 and $1,300 per year, Michigan’s average annual cost for standard auto insurance is known to top $2,200. There are quite a few reasons for this, which we’ll get into below.